Best of 2005 – #25 – The Mountain Goats

sunset tree
The Mountain Goats – The Sunset Tree

I like to make mix CD’s for my friends. I like to make mix CD’s and leave them in random places for someone to discover, and hopefully fall in love with the songs that I like. I like to turn people on to music that they would never seek out or buy without that push in the right direction. I put the Mountain Goats, “Dance Music” on a lot of these mixes, and most of the reactions I got from friends and strangers was about that song. I lot of people can’t get past John Darnielle’s voice, saying it’s too nasal for them. I can get past it, in fact, I don’t mind it. The stories in his songs are powerful and informative. Lyrically, I think this album may be one of the strongest out this year.

From Coke Machine Glow:

Darnielle has given us a story that is impossibly painful, subject matter that is unreasonable to expect the most self-referential artists to dissect, and he’s fucking nailed it.

What the critics say:

Coke Machine Glow – 89%
Tiny Mix Tapes – 4/5
Metacritic.com – 82/100
Pitchfork – [7.2]

Buy it at Insound! Enter coupon code: muzzle05 for a 10% discount!!!

You can see the rest of my 2005 favorites (so far) by clicking here.

3 Responses to “Best of 2005 – #25 – The Mountain Goats”

  1. eric 07. Dec, 2005 at 2:19 pm #

    “I like to make mix CD’s and leave them in random places for someone to discover”

    Brilliant! I do the same thing. Earlier this year, I left a “party” mix in the mailbox of my overly fratty neighbors, who were fond of playing the worst dance music at 2am. Later that month, I heard LCD Soundsystem coming from their house and slept like a baby.

  2. uwmryan 07. Dec, 2005 at 2:22 pm #

    That’s great. I used to party at this one place back in the day, and I would always burn them tons of music because I really didn’t want to hear the same OAR album a million times over.

  3. kara 07. Dec, 2005 at 8:43 pm #

    OAR is coming to Ann Arbor! I’m definately not going.

Leave a Reply