Posted on Friday 6 May 2011
By Steven Spoerl
Okkervil River is my favorite band. It’s not a statement I can make easily but it’s truthful. Ever since hearing Unless It’s Kicks for the first time and subsequently seeking out their entire discography I’ve found myself being constantly won over. The starkly depraved emotional songs, the dark bursts of violence, the dazzling wordplay and narrative all set to loosely structured music that seemed to breathe on its own was something I could place myself firmly behind. I’d rank every single one of their LP’s amongst the best of the 2000’s without hesitation- as well as their EP’s.
So, it should be no surprise that I had extremely high expectations for the soon-to-be-released I Am Very Far. Bandleader Will Sheff had said in interviews that he wanted the band to be terrifyingly concise (like a fascist machine) for this record- and it shows. Musically, I Am Very Far differs in both sound and structure from anything else they’ve ever put to tape. Almost clinical. The songwriting’s as strong as it’s ever been which shouldn’t be a surprise. At this point in time it’s almost common knowledge (or it should be) that Sheff is operating as one of the finest lyricists contemporary music has to offer. However, this time around the songwriting’s of a more ambiguous and vague nature- some of the themes (particularly that of violence) have been retained and brought to the forefront as a nice complement to their occasional nightmare imagery- which is a return to a particular brand of form (namely their Black Sheep Boy
era) that the band works wonders with.
A lot’s been said about the recording methods of I Am Very Far (recording to tape, employing rooms full of guitarists, two drummers, orchestra sections, etc) but thus far, no one’s delved much into the actual songs. So, here’s a brief track-by-track summary.
The Valley: Opening with an effectively syncopated and palm-muted guitar progression and then being viciously interrupted by a gunshot snare is a beautiful opening- some nice instrumental flourishes are added but all ears are tuned in to the first verse here- and it’s quite a verse. Instead of the typical detail-centric rambling we’re treated to this; “We watch the sun switching in the sky, off and on, where our friend stands bleeding on the late summer lawn. A slicked back bloody black gunshot to the head- he has fallen to the valley of the rock n’ roll dead.” The song continues on to reveal their aforementioned friend’s throat’s been slit and at large, they seem somewhat indifferent about it as if they’re enveloped by some sort of barely-described dystopia- and are cranking out the music to match. It’s a hell of an opener- and rivals Our Life Is Not A Movie or Maybe as their absolute best opening track.
Piratess: This is where things get intriguing- the song opens with a cold pulsating electro beat that’s somewhat reminiscent of Talking Heads. They eventually add some electricity that comes surging through at all the right times- along with some fairly subtle instrumental tricks (faint bells and tape hiss). It’s fascinating to listen to and the closest to a dance song Okkervil’s ever made. However, most dance songs don’t include subject matter this violent- for proof here are the lyrics to the stunning last verse (as heard over a restrained and sustained organ); “Oh murderess, in the wilderness, with your victims all around you. As their combined love forms a pool your knife’s reflected in, now I’m ready too, with my throat to you. On this mountain, by this moon and what I want the most to do- is prove I’m not like them.”
Rider: Perhaps the closest song on this record to their more recent songs (The Stage Names/The Stand Ins). It actually sounds somewhat similar to Pop Lie and reminded me more than once of The New Pornographers (who had Will Sheff contribute guest vocals on their last album). It’s a fantastic rollicking rock n’ roll song that shambles along with glee, while maintaining the darker mood and theme of the album (by the end of the song, the narrator’s got a hole in his throat and is screaming)- an impressive feat. It ends in a fiery cacophony of noise as if to indicate some explosive disaster.
It’s the little things like that which convince me Okkervil River is one of the smartest (and best) bands making music today.
Lay of the Last Survivor: One of the few songs I was lucky enough to hear before I Am Very Far’s official release. However, I’d only been listening to a live acoustic solo version and as such was particularly excited to hear the studio version. After a few spins, I’m not sure which I prefer yet, they’re both gorgeous. The live version’s a little more heartfelt but there’s lush instrumentation on the studio version that props it up and makes it even more beautiful. Once again, it proves to be an adequate example of Will Sheff’s enviable songwriting prowess and includes another gorgeously sorrowful conclusion; “How right, we felt, with our hands tightly closed around something we broke- and then our whimpering sisters, sobbing well-wishers. Well, it’s over… just let my hand go.” Incredible.
White Shadow Waltz: Another song that reminded me a little bit of The New Pornographers (and, surprisingly, DeVotchka) at the start before expanding into something distinctly unique. It is here something becomes apparent; Okkervil River have succeeded in doing something next-to-impossible with I Am Very Far; creating a style. Not style mimicry- but style creation. All of the songs here share distinct traits and will, in time, become instantly recognizable as songs from I Am Very Far. I’m not even sure how to begin to describe what they’ve achieved here, musically. I can tell it’s complex, innovative, and a little challenging. There are elements of discord and unity. The narrative here is particularly unbelievable- following a character referred to only as White Shadow Waltz. It’s unquestionably one of the bands most striking works that demands attention and repeated listens.
We Need A Myth: Early word was that this was one of the band’s best songs to date. After multiple reasons, I find no reason to disagree. Everything great the band’s done from their earliest days (the Bedroom EP and Stars Too Small to Use) right up through their late work (everything from The Stage Names to the previous tracks on I Am Very Far) is brilliantly distilled here in a singular track. It’s dazzling to listen to and may rival White Shadow Waltz as their most inventive track. The amount of effective style changes is breathtaking (just like, as always, Sheff’s wordplay). “We Need A Myth’s” climactic moment is probably their best since either “Another Radio Song” off the Black Sheep Boy Appendix or “The War Criminal Rises and Speaks” off of Down the River of Golden Dreams. I’ve never heard a crucifixion analogy as unpretentious as the one “We Need A Myth” ends on. It’s a staggering work and one that I’ll be listening to far too many times in the future.
Hanging From A Hit: Opening with a musical intro that sounds startlingly similar to the score work of Jon Brion’s always enough to get my attention. It’s the albums quietest moment but just as engaging as any of the others. Utilizing a beautiful melody set over a waltz time signature it eventually works its way into a passionate climactic point. Okkervil River has always understood song structure- and just as importantly, overall sequencing- which is an aspect more and more bands are losing grasp of. In any other number slot, this song’s effectiveness would lessen but placed here, it’s perfect and more than that, necessary. Will Sheff also proves once again, that he’s one of the finest describers of damaged relationships; “And she says I smile polite, I tip and tithe and I see the sights with a well-trained eye. But I calmly cry, because I’m too much mine without him.” By the time the song’s ended, in case you thought they’d lost the darker violence element, there’s a beautifully worded description of a fiery death. It’s just more sorrowful than violent this time.
Show Yourself: “Show Yourself” starts off as an excellent song. It just has the misfortune of being grouped into an album with unbelievable songs making it the probable subject of being quickly skipped over. It prods along exuding minimalist restraint, something Okkervil’s been shying away from recently. Luckily, the narrative (particularly ambiguous here) is striking enough to keep listeners listening and by the end the band’s rallied themselves into as appropriate of a fury as the song requires. However, all that said, this is probably the weakest song on the record- which says quite a damn lot about this record.
Your Past Life As A Blast: Another intriguing departure for Okkervil River happens when this song morphs into something that could probably be adequately explained as “quasi-disco”. Yet again, though, disco doesn’t generally contain subject matter this dark- from “your throat, where it’s exposed, looks like a crime” to a desire for “you to come over here and do me violence”. It’s somewhat reminiscent of Arcade Fire which makes a whole lot of sense. The two bands share several similarities in musicianship, thematic content, and influence. Would’ve loved to have seen the show they recently played together in Dallas- fingers crossed for a joint tour in the future. Aside from all that, “Your Past Life As A Blast” succeeds again as both a transition piece as well as a context piece- while still being an excellent song. It serves as the perfect relaxed set-up for…
Wake and Be Fine: The first of the songs on I Am Very Far to be unveiled, first on Late Night with Jimmy Fallon (a performance which I probably watched about 50 times within a few weeks) and then as an available download on the site. It’s perhaps the most forceful song on the record and the most representative. The fiery lyrics, the vicious instrumentation, and the successful experimentation with expansion- everything distinctive about this album can be found here. It’s yet another spectacular triumph for the band as it’s even more powerful in the context of the LP as it was as a standalone single. That’s extremely impressive- and at 3:25 is the shortest track on the record, making it even more of a staggering gut-punch. It’s fiery, it’s concise, it’s a little bit terrifying, and it’s still one of the best things I’ve heard this year.
The Rise: From the shortest song on the record, to the longest; the grand finale. Opening with a minor chord piano progression it works itself into a crescendo augmented by a distortion-tinged electric guitar- the story seems to document either an impending apocalypse or an already-arrived dystopia. The latter of which would make sense in the context of the other songs on the record. There’s a rise and fall- and another insane musical interlude that- dare I say- reminded me a lot of The Beatles studio experiments.
It’s a fitting cap on what’s so far proven to be the year’s best record- quiet, restrained, violent, cold, empty, ambiguous, and wonderful.
I Am Very Far isn’t a record you should buy, it’s a record you need to buy from a band you should’ve already been paying attention to. For all of the lineup changes and style alterations- for all the self-imposed limitations and goals, Okkervil River have emerged with a record that could very well prove to be their absolute best. On May 10th, with no hesitation, I’m buying this record. On June 12th, I’ll number among those standing in line hours early outside of First Ave. & 7th St. Entry in Minneapolis to see Future Islands, Titus Andronicus (another favorite), and Okkervil River. I suggest you all do the same. Both the album and the show are trips worth taking.
MP3: Okkervil River – “Wake and Be Fine”
++
Pre-Order: Okkervil River – I Am Very Far



















